Category: DISCUSSION
You have two hydraulic systems, a high volume low pressure for the scraper and high pressure low volume for the tractor/blade, small leaks which allow the blade or scraper to drop overnight won't make much difference to operation. If the scraper rams are double the volume of the blade rams, their operating speed will be half the blade rams. If a ram is the same length and 1.5 times the diameter of another, its volume is getting close to double. We need more detail of ram dimensions for this question. Meanwhile, do a blocked cylinder test, hold the scraper up with a crane, disconnect the hydraulic lines, if they aren't quick couplers, the lines will need to be blanked off, then let the crane off. If the scraper still creeps down, you can forget any seal or spool leaks in the control valve, the fault is in the ram seals.
Guys
Attached some pictures that relate to a number of my posts on this topic plus a few others.
But first in response to a number of your suggestions I have determined that:
1. the scoop rams are not leaking as they hold when the tractor is running and turned off (I did as Catsilver suggested)
2. the blade rams are not leaking much as they hold when the tractor is running and turned off for several hours
3. swapping the blade and implement circuits made a small difference in the slow lift of the scoop such that it is now just usable particularly if I don't fully load it. The blade also lifts nearly as fast (acceptable) as it did before the swap. To get the scoop to lift I have to run the tractor at full revs while I can lift the blade at much lower revs.
So based on what you have told me it looks like I don't have a problem with blade or scoop rams nor the valve spools. That leaves pressure relief valve and pump performance does it not? I cant measure pump flow or pressure as I don't have the diagnostic equipment.
The photos
1. the scoop which shows the log stroke but fairly small bore rams and the half inch hoses which implies it should run on a modern high pressure system does it not?
2. 2 photos showing the broken cast iron ram retainer (gland packing ring) and my home made solution. I have a lathe so instead of paying $700 quoted for repair I turned up 2 pieces of mild steel, bored 4 holes for the bolts (not shown) and now have a working ram that doesn't leak a drop. I still need to turn a recess for a wiper seal when I get one.
3. my new stick rake still to be fitted by the manufacturer. Cost me $13000 which included delivery and fitting from a firm in Bundaberg which is about 7 hours driving from here.
4. my scrub canopy work in progress - using 75x50 RHS, a lot of welding rods and eventually to be sheeted with galvanised walkway expanded mesh that I got for free. Also to do a guard above the fuel tank to protect my back and a side guard on the right side down to the footplate. Note that this is not a true ROPS structure but is intended to protect me and the dozer from the smaller regrowth scrub I will be clearing. I wont put a tree pusher on so I won't be tempted to try pushing big trees down.
Ian